Pouch Barrier Material Comparison: decision and evidence matrix
| Layer direction, outside to inside | Question to resolve | Evidence to compare | Approval limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| PET/PE | Does the transparent structure meet the product’s moisture, oxygen and light needs? | Exact layer thicknesses, film data, OTR/WVTR conditions and seal window. | Transparency and polymer names do not establish the required shelf life. |
| PET/VMPET/PE | Does the metallized construction retain its required barrier after converting and handling? | Exact metallized grade, transmission tests, flex and seal review. | Metallization alone does not establish a numerical barrier value. |
| PET/AL/PE | Does the foil construction fit the light, barrier and handling requirements? | Foil thickness, laminate condition, pinhole/flex review and finished-pack checks. | Foil structure does not remove seal, puncture or handling risks. |
| PE-based barrier direction, potentially including EVOH | Can the exact construction meet both product protection and destination-market recycling criteria? | All layers, coatings, adhesives, zipper, barrier fraction and current scheme assessment. | A PE label or EVOH layer does not independently prove recyclability or product suitability. |
Published film data: numerical examples with test conditions
Reviewed November 5, 2026. These are third-party film or resin-grade references, not StandPouchy laminate specifications. Values measured under different humidity, thickness or normalization conventions cannot be ranked as equivalent pouch performance.
| Published material / specimen | OTR reference | WVTR / MVTR reference | Conditions and scope |
|---|---|---|---|
| Toray Lumirror MK6HB metallized PET; 9, 12.2 or 23.4 µm | 0.078 cm³/(m²·day); ASTM D3985 at 23°C, 0% RH | 0.078 g/(m²·day); ASTM F1249 at 38°C, 50% RH | Typical film values in Toray sheet DS-00179/3; not binding specifications or a converted-pouch test. [1] |
| Prior Chemical VM-PET-1; measured thickness 12.3 µm | 0.2 cm³/(m²·day); ASTM D3985 at 23°C, 50% RH | 0.3 g/(m²·day); ASTM F1249 at 38°C, 90% RH | Supplier internal test values; target limits are ≤1 for each metric. Supplier states results are not guaranteed. [2] |
| Kuraray EVAL E105B; cast-film grade, normalized to 20 µm | 1.9 cm³·20µm/(m²·day·atm); ISO 21309-2 Annex C | Not provided in the cited grade sheet | 20°C, 65% RH. Grade sheet updated August 7, 2020; this is not a PE/EVOH/PE pouch result. [3] |
Which fields make OTR and WVTR data comparable?
Record OTR in cm³/(m²·24 h) and WVTR in g/(m²·24 h), together with method, temperature, relative humidity on each side where applicable, gas conditions, specimen thickness, conditioning and detection limit. Keep film transmission separate from whole-package results. Ask for the actual report and its sample identity; do not infer a value from a similar-looking laminate.
What changes between film and a filled pouch?
Zippers, windows, seals, folds, valves, flexing and the filling process can change the result. Match the film report to the ordered structure and review representative converted pouches with the real product. Shelf-life approval needs product-specific storage and acceptance evidence.
Separate food-contact evidence from recycling claims.
| Review area | Scope to verify | Project evidence |
|---|---|---|
| US food contact | Identify the relevant authorization for each food-contact substance and intended use; 21 CFR 177.1520 concerns olefin polymers and is not a blanket approval for an entire laminate. | Complete structure, intended food and time/temperature conditions, and applicable supplier documentation. |
| EU plastic food contact | Check the applicable scope of Regulation (EU) No 10/2011 and its current amendments, alongside other relevant food-contact rules. | Construction-matched declaration and supporting migration evidence for intended conditions. |
| Packaging and recycling claims | Assess the exact finished construction and destination requirements separately from food-contact suitability. | Current market-specific criteria and an assessment identifying the layers, inks, adhesives and closures. |
Check the current official texts and the intended use with the responsible compliance reviewer.